Library/Deal Strategy & Stakeholder Management/Objection Handling & Risk Reduction/Respond to 'We Tried This Before and It Failed' Objection
TestedDeal Strategy & Stakeholder ManagementQuick Win (under 10 min)

Respond to 'We Tried This Before and It Failed' Objection

Generate an email response that acknowledges a prospect's past failure with your solution category and offers a

About this prompt

This prompt produces an email under 130 words for when a prospect has tried your solution category before and it didn't work. It helps AEs and inside sales reps acknowledge the past experience without being defensive, ask a specific diagnostic question, and offer a low-risk way to demonstrate difference. Use it in early evaluation when past failure is the primary barrier to moving the deal forward.A prior failure objection is harder than a standard competitive objection — the prospect has firsthand evidence that this category of solution doesn't work, and dismissing that experience will kill the deal. This prompt structures a response that does the opposite: takes the failure seriously, asks a genuinely curious diagnostic question about what went wrong, explains how [YOUR SOLUTION] differs from what they experienced, and closes with a low-risk next step (pilot, reference call, sandbox demo). Fill in [YOUR SOLUTION CATEGORY] to set the context, and if you know [THE PREVIOUS SOLUTION THEY TRIED] and [WHAT WENT WRONG], include those — the more specific the input, the sharper the differentiation in the output. Without knowing what failed, the AI will generate a generic differentiation paragraph; that's the weakest part of the response, so push your own product knowledge into that section. This prompt is most useful for AEs running competitive displacement deals where the incumbent isn't a competitor but a previous attempt at your own category.

The prompt

A prospect has tried [YOUR SOLUTION CATEGORY] before and it didn't work. They're skeptical. Write a response that: 1. Takes their past experience seriously — don't minimize it 2. Asks a specific quest
The rest of this prompt is Pro.Copying the full text is Pro. Browsing stays free, and 100 prompts are free in full.
Start Pro — $4.99/monthSee the free prompts
Copy prompt
☆ Save to library
Send to a teammate
Email it
Link copied — paste it in Slack
Open in
ClaudeChatGPTCopilotGemini
Copying the full text is Pro.

Variables to replace

YOUR SOLUTION CATEGORY|YOUR SOLUTION|IF KNOWN

How to run it

  1. Copy the prompt and paste it into Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, or Copilot — it's tuned to run in any of them.
  2. Replace the variables — swap each bracketed token for your deal's specifics. The variables list above explains every field.
  3. Make it yours — run it, keep what's strong, and tighten your inputs on the next pass. The prompt improves with your context.

What good output looks like

Make it yours

StageEvaluation
SeatAE, Inside Sales
DifficultyIntermediate
Time to valueQuick Win (under 10 min)
Works withAI-Agnostic
CategoryDeal Strategy & Stakeholder Management
Promptifi ProFull text of all 2,900+ prompts, every workflow, unlimited saves.Start Pro — $4.99/moor $99 once, lifetime
You're ProFull library open. Copy, save, and chain anything.
More from the library

Reps who ran this also ran.

Evaluation
PRO

Write Live-Call Rebuttals for Three Common Objections

This prompt produces natural-sounding spoken rebuttals for up to three sales objections, each under 50 words and built for use in a live call rather than a written response. It is built for AEs, inside sales reps, sales managers preparing coaching material, and founder-led sellers who need to handle recurring objections consistently. Use it when you have identified the specific objections your deals run into and want structured, ready-to-speak responses.

AE, Inside Sales, Sales Manager, Founder-Led SellerAI-Agnostic
Open →
Discovery
PRO

Extract Deal Intelligence from Call Transcript

This prompt helps AEs and Sales Engineers extract structured deal intelligence from a discovery or qualification call transcript. It produces a stakeholder map, key intelligence summary, current-state environment snapshot, red and green flags, MEDPICC scoring with rationale, and prioritized next steps. Use it immediately after any prospect call where you need to update your CRM, align internally, or prepare for the next conversation.

AE, Sales EngineerAI-Agnostic
Open →
Prospecting
PRO

Generate 10 Angle-Diverse Cold Email Variants Under 75 Words

This prompt generates ten cold email variants — one per named angle — each under 75 words, built around a no-oriented question and an easy out. It is designed for SDRs, BDRs, and AEs who need a full A/B test suite for a specific persona and industry without duplicating approach or question type. Use it when you are launching a new sequence and want to cover the full angle spectrum before committing to a primary message.

SDR,BDR,AEAI-Agnostic
Open →

Stop rewriting. Start closing.

Browse the librarySee pricing
Copy prompt
Start Pro — $4.99/mo